Private lawyer vs. Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE) for failure to appoint the Scientific Council on Climate Change

Location

Costa Rica

Status
Resolved at first instance
Case file number
26-024058-0007-CO
Start date
July 3, 2026
Date of judgment or latest existing decision
September 10, 2026. Resolved in the first and only instance erga omnes. By Resolution No. 2026034743, the Constitutional Chamber declared the appeal admissible.
Summary

Appeal for Protection before the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice of Costa Rica, promoted against the Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE) for the omission, sustained for more than four years and throughout three successive administrations (2018-2022, 2022-2026 and 2026-2030), to designate the members of the Scientific Council of Climate Change ("4C"), body created by Executive Decree No. 40615-MINAE of August 7, 2017.

The 4C is the only institutional mechanism for independent scientific advice on climate change within Costa Rican institutions, comprised of academics and experts appointed based on merit, with the authority to issue autonomous pronouncements. Its lack of integration since the expiration of its first cohort's term in 2022 has left the Climate Change Directorate (DCC) of the Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE) without this institutionalized scientific input, even during the development of the 2025-2035 Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), despite the fact that NDC 3.0 continues to recognize the 4C as part of the country's existing climate architecture under the UNFCCC.

The complaint argued:

  • The violation of the human right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment in its substantive element of a healthy climate, as well as the conventional right to science in its procedural dimension.

  • The failure to comply with a regulated competence of periodic designation (article 9 of Decree 40615-MINAE), the exercise of which, according to the public admission of a former vice minister of Environment, does not require legal reform or additional budget.

  • De facto regression with respect to a level of institutional protection already achieved (the 4C was fully integrated between 2018 and 2022), contrary to the principles of progressivity and non-regression in environmental matters.

  • De facto replacement of the 4C by informal and unsystematic consultations with "expert people" for the preparation of the current NDC, which does not meet the inter-American standard of best available science.

  • Triple concurrence of the hypotheses of article 29 of the Law of Constitutional Jurisdiction: consummated violation, current violation and threat of future violation.

The plaintiff requested that the Constitutional Chamber declare the protection admissible and order the Minister of Environment and Energy to issue the official designation of the members of the Scientific Council on Climate Change (4C) and proceed to its formal installation, restoring the operation of the only independent scientific advisory body on climate matters that the country has.

Furthermore, the litigation aimed to: (i) recognize that the sustained omission to appoint the members of the 4C constitutes a continued violation of the rights to a healthy environment, to enjoy a healthy climate and, for the first time as an autonomous right: the right to science in its procedural dimension in the terms developed in OC-32/25; (ii) order MINAE to issue, within a peremptory period, the official appointment of the members of the 4C in accordance with articles 3 and 9 of Executive Decree No. 40615-MINAE; (iii) order the formal installation of the new generation of members of the 4C and their accreditation before the Court as a mechanism for monitoring compliance with the judgment; (iv) that the standard of material (and not merely formal) sufficiency of institutional climate protection mechanisms be consolidated in constitutional jurisprudence, distinguishing the existence of ad hoc scientific inputs from the existence and functioning of an independent and regulated mechanism; and, (v) that the State be condemned to pay costs, damages and losses caused, to be liquidated in execution of judgment before the contentious-administrative jurisdiction.

On September 10, 2026, the appeal was upheld, and it was ordered that, within a maximum period of two months from the notification of this judgment, all actions within its jurisdiction be carried out to appoint the members of the Scientific Council on Climate Change. The State was ordered to pay the costs, damages, and losses caused by the events that form the basis of this ruling, which will be determined in the execution of the judgment in the administrative litigation.

Implementation

Through a document submitted on November 3, 2026, CARTA-MINAE-DM-1047-2026, within the case file, the Minister of Environment and Energy presents a report on compliance with sentence 2026-34743, designation and officialization of the members of the Scientific Council on Climate Change.

Climate element

The creation and formation of the Scientific Council on Climate Change provides a specialized space to contribute technical and scientific evidence on:

  • The current and future impacts of climate change.
  • The vulnerability of Costa Rican ecosystems and territories.
  • Measures to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions.
  • Climate adaptation and resilience strategies.
  • The evaluation and guidance of public climate policies.

The central point is that state decisions related to climate change must be based on up-to-date and verifiable scientific information, preventing environmental policies from depending exclusively on political or administrative criteria.

Claimants
  • Mario Peña Chacón
Defendants
  • Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE)
Territorial context

Costa Rica is a Central American country characterized by significant biological and ecosystemic richness. Its territory includes tropical forests, mangroves, wetlands, coastlines on the Pacific Ocean and the Caribbean Sea, as well as mountain ranges and river basins.

This ecological diversity also implies a high exposure to the effects of climate change, including:

- Changes in precipitation patterns.

- Droughts and water scarcity in certain regions.

- Floods and extreme weather events.

- Impacts on forest and coastal ecosystems.

- Vulnerability of rural and coastal communities.

- Impacts on biodiversity and productive activities.

In this context, the Scientific Council on Climate Change acquires national importance, since its contributions can help ensure that public decisions take into account the environmental and territorial particularities of the country.

Rules and principles invoked

International agreements/treaties

  • Paris Agreement, Law No. 9405 (articles 7 and 8)
  • American Convention on Human Rights (articles 1, 2, 8, 25 and 26)
  • American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man (Article XIII)
  • Additional Protocol to the American Convention on Human Rights in the Area of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights / Protocol of San Salvador (articles 1, 11 and 14.2)
  • United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, Law No. 7414 (articles 4 and 5)

Jurisprudence of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACHR)

  • Residents of La Oroya vs. Peru , Judgment of November 27, 2023 (para. 191, standard of best available science; principles of progressivity and non-regression).
  • International Court of Justice (ICJ): Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change , Advisory Opinion of 23 July 2025 (paras. 234-254 and 283-286, due diligence standard and best available scientific information).

National laws

  • Political Constitution of the Republic of Costa Rica (Articles 6, 7, 21, 46, and 50
  • Executive Decree No. 40615-MINAE, "Creation of the Scientific Council on Climate Change" (articles 1, 3, 4, 9 and 10)
  • Law of Constitutional Jurisdiction (articles 1, 2, 29, 49 and related articles)

Beginning

  • Principle of progressivity and non-regression
  • Intergenerational principle or principle of intergenerational equity and solidarity
  • Principle of due diligence
Links of interest
Instance
Constitutional
Actor type
Natural person
Topic
Acuerdo de París y compromisos climáticos
Intergenerational justice
Obligations of States
Citizen participation
Environmental protection
Violation of human rights
Defendant type
State
Grounds for claim
Paris Agreement and climate commitments
OC 32/25 Inter-American Court of Human Rights
Right to a healthy environment
National legislation
Regional or international treaties
Other human rights
Implementation status
Implementado