CDMX Mexico
In 2013, Mexico carried out a constitutional reform in energy matters that included, in its Seventeenth Transitory Article, an express mandate to the Congress of the Union to update the legal framework of the energy sector incorporating environmental protection criteria: energy efficiency, reduction of greenhouse gases (GHG), low carbon footprint and clean energy obligations for the electricity industry.
Ten years later, the Inter-American Association for Environmental Defense (AIDA-Mexico) and the Mexican Center for Environmental Defense (CEMDA) sued the Mexican Congress, arguing that it had failed to comply with the 2013 mandate by not legislating specifically to reduce and eventually prohibit the use of coal in electricity generation. The lawsuit stated that this omission violated the human rights to a healthy environment and to the health of the affected people.
The Supreme Court denied the injunction by a vote of 7 to 2, arguing that the mandate did not require legislation specifically on coal but rather on sustainability in general, and that Congress is already fulfilling this general obligation through the existing legal framework. However, the Court acknowledged that the State's environmental commitments are permanent and evolving, and that the authorities have a responsibility to continue strengthening environmental protection.
Among the arguments presented by the plaintiffs were the following:
a) Unconstitutional legislative omission
The 2013 constitutional mandate required Congress to legislate to ensure the gradual reduction of coal use and its eventual prohibition in electricity generation.
At the time of the lawsuit, there was no law that incorporated specific mechanisms to gradually eliminate coal from the national electricity system.
The lack of such legislation allowed Mexico to continue, and even expand, the capacity of its coal-fired power plants, several of which had already exceeded their 40-year lifespan.
b) The violation of human rights
The right to a healthy environment was violated because (1) it results in a failure to meet GHG emission reduction commitments, (2) it does not take into account the best available scientific information and (3) it is incompatible with the principle of progressivity.
The right to health is directly affected by air pollution from coal, especially in communities near coal-fired power plants.
The legislative omission perpetuated the violation of these rights indefinitely.
c) Binding international commitments
The IPCC states that by 2050 the use of coal must be almost entirely eliminated to meet the 1.5°C and 2°C pathways of the Paris Agreement.
The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) has indicated that the only option to meet climate goals by 2030 is to commit to an economic recovery away from coal.
Mexico signed the Global Partnership for the Phase-Out of Coal (2017), the Silesia Declaration (COP24) and the Glasgow Pact (COP26), committing to gradually reduce the use of coal.
These international commitments are relevant for interpreting the scope of constitutional mandates on environmental protection.
The Court denied the injunction; however, the ruling contains important legal recognitions that set valuable precedents for climate litigation in Mexico and the region.
It adopts the jurisprudential criterion that the qualified legitimate interest of environmental organizations can be proven through their corporate purpose established in their articles of incorporation.
The Mexican State has a permanent and progressive obligation to reduce polluting emissions and move towards a sustainable energy model.
It is clear that meeting climate mitigation obligations requires a structural transformation of energy systems. This implies making progress in replacing high-emission sources, such as coal, with lower-carbon technologies and renewable sources.
NDC 3.0 is part of the set of regulatory and public policy measures aimed at decarbonizing the electricity system.
The energy transition must be based on the best available scientific information, intergenerational justice, and the sustainability of national development.
Congress and other competent authorities retain the responsibility to continue promoting regulatory and administrative actions that strengthen environmental protection.
The ruling reiterates that the Mexican State does have a constitutional and conventional obligation to protect the right to a healthy environment in the face of climate change, and therefore the authorities must promote effective public policies to reduce polluting emissions.
This is the first case in Mexico, and one of the first in Latin America, in which the Supreme Court thoroughly analyzes the relationship between legislative omissions, climate constitutional mandates, and the use of specific fossil fuels.
The recognition of the principle of environmental progressivity and the evolving nature of climate commitments establishes useful legal foundations for litigation in other countries of the region.
International climate commitments, like conventional mandates, generate specific legislative obligations.
With this, another Court in Latin America offers interpretative clues to conclude that the NDC 3.0 contains binding obligations.
The climatic element of this litigation lies in the intention to develop a specific legislative framework that allows the responsible phase-out of coal in the generation of electricity in Mexico, in compliance with the mandate established in the Seventeenth Transitory Article of the 2013 energy constitutional reform, under a scheme of just and climate-responsible energy transition.
The organizations AIDA-Mexico and CEMDA argued that the continued use of coal for electricity generation is incompatible with national and international climate change mitigation obligations due to the high greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions produced by this fossil fuel. They also argued that keeping coal-fired power plants in operation, some of which are older than their estimated lifespan, hinders the achievement of the Paris Agreement goals and the scientific pathways necessary to limit global warming to 1.5°C. This case, therefore, underscores the need for Mexican energy policy to move toward a just energy transition based on clean energy, emissions reduction, and the protection of human rights.
- Inter-American Association for Environmental Defense (AIDA-Mexico)
- Mexican Center for Environmental Defense (CEMDA)
- Congress of the Union
This litigation has national scope, as it challenges the fossil fuel-based electricity generation model and its repercussions on the environment, climate, and public health. However, its effects manifest themselves differently in the regions where coal-fired power plants are located, particularly in areas linked to coal mining in Coahuila and the Nava power generation facilities, as well as in the communities near these infrastructures. These territories face problems associated with coal extraction and combustion, such as air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, and exposure of the population to pollutants harmful to health. In this sense, the litigation transcends the discussion on the regulation of the electricity sector, as it highlights the unequal territorial distribution of environmental and climate burdens.
Although the Supreme Court denied the injunction because it considered that the constitutional mandate did not require legislation specifically on the elimination of coal, it recognized the permanent and evolving nature of state obligations for environmental protection, which keeps in force the duty to progressively strengthen the legal framework to face the climate crisis and guarantee the rights to a healthy environment and to health.
International agreements/treaties
- Paris Agreement (particularly the Nationally Determined Contributions to reduce greenhouse gases)
- United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC)
- American Convention on Human Rights
National laws
- Political Constitution of the United Mexican States (CPEUM). Articles 1 and 4
- Seventeenth Transitory Article of the 2013 Energy Reform
- General Law on Climate Change (LGCC)
- Energy Transition Law (LTE)
- General Law of Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection (LGEEPA)
- The legislation of the electricity sector (also considering the constitutional reforms of 2024 and the issuance of the new Electricity Sector Law in 2025)
Beginning
- Principle of prevention
- Principle of best available scientific information
- Environmental progressivity and non-regression
- pro persona principle and legality